Get instant access to must-read content today!To access hundreds of features, subscribe today! At a time when the world is forced to go digital more than ever before just to stay connected, discover the in-depth content our subscribers receive every month by subscribing to gasworld.Don’t just stay connected, stay at the forefront – join gasworld and become a subscriber to access all of our must-read content online from just $270. Subscribe
There was a time, in those unreconstructed days before the Judicial Appointments Commission (JAC), when a woman would be turned down for judicial appointment simply because her skirt was deemed too short. Or she looked bookish or spinsterish or headmistressy. Or wore too much make-up. Yes, those were the days, not so long ago, when being pale, male and stale was a positive advantage when trying to get your rump on the bench. That’s a white-skinned man who’s past his best-buy date for those of you who don’t like rhymes. It also helped if you had been to public school and then Oxbridge, spoke posh, played golf, belonged to the right clubs and had the letters QC after your moniker. You needed to be ‘straight’, too, of course, as well as pale, male and stale. After all, it would be entirely inappropriate to have gay men disporting themselves in a judge’s sober ermine and silk. Thankfully, that’s all behind us now and the JAC is busily creating a diverse judiciary that reflects the make up of the country upon which it sits in judgment. Or is it? Some 70% of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) lawyers believe that the judicial selection process still discriminates against them. And the same proportion says they would be likely to apply for a judicial role themselves if there were more existing judges as role models who were openly gay. This all comes from a report prepared by LGBT network the InterLaw Diversity Forum based on a survey of more than 150 practising LGBT lawyers. Some 85-90% of respondents said that the creation of the JAC was a ‘positive development’ towards countering perceived prejudice in the selection process. But there is a still a long way to go, although the JAC is now monitoring the sexual orientation of applicants to ensure that the judiciary reflects and serves the whole of society. InterLaw founder Daniel Winterfeldt, partner at City firm CMS Cameron McKenna, said: ‘It is vital that the judiciary is seen to reflect the society it serves because confidence in the judiciary is so central to the functioning of a fair society.’ The diversity of the judiciary is clearly a hot topic at the moment because no less august a body than the House of Lords is also getting in on the act. Last week saw the first evidence session of a House of Lords constitution committee inquiry into the fairness and effectiveness of the present judicial appointments system. Cheryl Thomas, professor of judicial studies at University College London, told the committee that political leadership was required to achieve diversity. That’s an audacious statement in a country where the independence of the judiciary is the jewel in the crown of our legal system! ‘President Clinton said that he wanted a judiciary that looked like America and that is what began to happen,’ Thomas said. ‘If we want diversity, we need political leadership.’ The argument convinced me. Professor Alan Paterson, director of the University of Strathclyde’s centre for professional legal studies, also supported political involvement, saying that it was not feasible to expect the present JAC to ‘break the log jam’ and make the judiciary genuinely diverse. He said: ‘This is only possible for politicians. ‘The appointments system was transformed in Canada because politicians said they wanted to see women and people from ethnic minorities who can do the job on every shortlist.’ Dr Erika Rackley, Durham University senior lecturer in law, said that there was no tension between merit and diversity if it was accepted that a diverse judiciary did a better job than a non-diverse one.’ The inquiry is expected to continue until the end of the year. So there you have it – progress on all fronts, albeit slow. Let me close with perhaps my favourite – if that’s the right word – anecdote about discrimination against women applying for the judiciary before the JAC came into existence. Praise was heaped upon a male barrister for arguing with ‘passionate conviction’ in court. A woman barrister, in contrast, was criticised for lacking emotional detachment. She was turned down for the judiciary: far too hysterical to become one of us, don’t you know, old boy….
Nondies would make a foray into KCB territory, forcing their hosts into an infringement. Simon Chege would drill home the penalty, slashing the deficit to 10-3. With Nondies on the under the cosh, Head Coach Kanyi Gitonga threw on Derrick Wamalwa, Edwin Alubaka, Ken Nyagetuba and Teddy Salano who had all been left on the bench. They would steady the ship but could not prevent prop forward Sidney Mwai from going over, again from a maul with Fabian Olando converting for a 20-3 lead. Former KCB player Wamalwa would go over, seeing his side trail 20-8 at the interval.A tentative start to the second half saw both sides engage cautious, but it was KCB who had the upper hand despite Gitonga’s side remaining competitive. With the half drawing on, it was the home side who saw more ball but thrice Olando’s decision making, opting to keep possession when it was more practical to commit his marker and release his support player cost the bankers try scoring opportunities. Ian Indimuli’s try was just reward for the Lions pressure, his bonus point try giving them a 25-8 before Wamalwa’s last gasp consolation try for Nondies saw the match end 25-15.Nakuru inflicted a second defeat in three matches to hosts Impala RFC, beating them 22-18 at the Impala Club while Mwamba registered a 64-8 win over Kisumu RFC at the Kisumu Polytechnic grounds.Quins and Homeboyz were not in action after their opponents, Strathmore and Mean Machine engaged in the Kenya University Games currently ongoing in Ruaraka.Collated Kenya Cup ResultsKCB 25 Nondies 15Impala 18 Nakuru 22Kisumu 8 Mwamba 640Shares0000(Visited 1 times, 1 visits today) 0Shares0000NAIROBI, Kenya, December 19- Kenya Commercial Bank registered a 25-15 win over Nondescript RUFC, closing out the calendar year unbeaten as the Kenya Cup league breaks for the festive season.This match at the Lions Den in Ruaraka saw the bankers go 5-0 ahead after only 22 seconds, when winger Darwin Mukidza grounded the ball after his team’s first phase attack. They would go 10-0 up when Eric Kabii, at the end of a rolling maul from a line out deep in Nondies territory went over.